Mistress America
“I am Jill's Smug, Strained Social Satire.”
Movie Reviews and More
Grade: B
Director: Mike Judge
Starring: Jason Bateman, Mila Kunis, Kristen Wiig, Ben Affleck, J.K. Simmons,
MPAA Rating: R
Running Time: 1 hour, 31 minutes
Mike Judge will never be confused with Woody Allen. However, each shares an affinity for satirical comedy drawn from the nuances of their respective habitats. For Allen, his voluminous filmography is usually set in America’s artistic epicenter, New York City, a fact that has also undoubtedly afforded Allen much critical leeway.
Whereas Allen wallows in the Upper East Side, Judge lives in the lower west side: Texas, in the workaday malaise of the American heartland. In contrast to the prolific Woodster, Judge’s sparse resume is a product of his renowned, sometimes inhibiting perfectionism. The creator of Beavis & Butthead and King of the Hill has directed only three live-action feature films; one of those, the star-crossed Idiocracy, is seen by some as Judge’s attempt to revisit Allen’s Sleeper.
In Extract, Judge’s talent for toeing the line of caricature without stooping to condescension is again on display. The film’s sardonic look at the workplace milieu immediately recalls Judge’s cult fave, Office Space. Jason Bateman plays Joel Reynold, the owner of a flavored extract factory beset by professional and personal woes. Joel yearns to sell his company and cash out for an early retirement, but a proposed deal with General Mills is threatened when an employee (Clifton Collins Jr.) sues after losing a gonad during a workplace accident.
At home, Joel is trapped in a sexless marriage, always arriving home just beyond the eight o’clock deadline after which his frosty wife, Suzie (Kristen Wiig), cinches up her sweatpants for the evening and settles in to watch Dancing with the Stars. Joel whiles away his nights at the local watering hole, where Dean (Ben Affleck) serves up drinks, half-baked-if-well-meaning advice, and assorted pharmacological remedies.
Within this inanity, there is a grifter named Cindy (Mila Kunis), who is looking to drain whichever poor sap into whom she can sink her comely claws. And, there’s a lunkheaded gigolo named Brad (Dustin Milligan) who takes his charge of seducing Suzie way too enthusiastically.
Bateman proves a worthy foil for scene-stealers Affleck, Koechner, and Gene Simmons (yep, that Gene Simmons) as a slimy, ambulance-chasing lawyer with the suitably reptilian name Joe Adler. However, the talents of Kunis and Wiig are underused, while Collins, J.K. Simmons, and the rest of the supporting cast fill flat, one-note characters.
Allusions to
More intriguingly, while Extract revolves around a white-collar lead who drives a Beemer and lives in a gated community, he represented as ultimately more dysfunctional than the redneck who swills Pepsi out of a 2-litter bottle while watching The American Outdoorsman on his giant rear-projection TV.
With this film, Mike Judge comes off as a working man’s Woody Allen … or a kindler, gentler Judd Apatow. Too bad he doesn’t make nearly as many movies.
Neil Morris
Grade: D –
Director: Woody Allen
Starring: Larry David, Evan Rachel Wood, Patricia Clarkson, and Ed Begley Jr.
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Running Time: 1 hour, 32 minutes
When will Woody Allen stop subjecting us to cinematic vehicles used to justify marrying his twenty-something stepdaughter? Yes, I know Allen supposedly wrote the screenplay for Whatever Works in the 1970s, and, indeed, its hoary air reeks of the bottom of the musty desk drawer that coughed up this misanthropic mistake. But, the story of an older man who finds himself in a May-December relationship with a comely ingénue he finds literally camped out on his stoop oozes with self-absorbed psychoanalysis.
If you ever wondered about the cosmic neuroticism that would emerge if Larry David were cast in a Woody Allen film, then Whatever Works is your answer. David plays Boris Yelnikoff, the standard-issue Allen stand-in, who ambles around Greenwich Village on a bum leg injured during a failed suicide attempt, spouting off random invectives against virtually everything and everyone, from health-conscious diets to religious zealots, from fear of terrorism to the young children to whom he futilely tries to teach chess. He boorishly peppers his vocabulary by incessantly labeling his intellectual inferiors “morons,” “cretins,” and “inchworms.” He even regularly breaks the fourth wall, wondering aloud why we, the audience, would bother buying tickets to watch a movie about his sad, uninteresting life story. Only the legion of Allen apologists would disagree.
Enter Melodie (Evan Rachel Wood), a NYC newcomer and former Southern beauty pageant queen with no money or board. Melodie charms her way into Boris’ brownstone and, eventually, his hardened heart. They eventually marry (although, curiously, Allen never captures a single moment of romantic intimacy between them, even a kiss), much to the chagrin of Melodie’s estranged, fundamentalist parents, Marietta (Patricia Clarkson) and John (Ed Begley Jr.).
Allen’s humorless, often unwatchable homage to secular humanism plays like bad community theater. The acerbic wit and browbeaten charm David embodies in Curb Your Enthusiasm turns dissonant in Allen’s hands. Wood occasionally flashes her innate acumen, but she suffers from a simplistic role and a hackneyed accent that sounds like something straight out of an episode of Hee Haw. Indeed, Boris/Allen’s constant barrage against Southerners is both artless and elitist. (At some one, Marietta tells Melodie she’s “living like a sharecropper.”)
From atop Allen’s lofty intellectual perch, a taste of Greenwich Village is all that is required to save Melodie and family from their backward, moralistic ways. Marietta dons a beret, finds her inner artiste, and carries on an open ménage à trois with two men. John, meanwhile, undergoes a ludicrous sexual awakening, realizing over drinks in a bar – and with virtually no sense of emotional turmoil – that he is homosexual. He then launches into a relationship with the first gay guy he meets (a slapdash sequence that reveals the elemental underpinning beneath Allen’s ostensible high-mindedness).
“Whatever works” is Boris’ credo about life and the search for happiness. To Allen’s ham-fisted handiwork, the only appropriate response is “whatever…”
Neil Morris
Grade: C +
Directed by: Woody Allen
Starring: Ewan McGregor, Colin Farrell, Hayley Atwell, Tom Wilkinson, and Philip Davis
MPAA Rating: R
Running Time: 1 hour, 48 minutes
After years stuck in the romantic comedy rut, Cassandra’s Dream is Woody Allen’s latest in a lineage that dates back to Crimes and Misdemeanors, which begat last year’s Match Point. It is also the third leg of his quasi-British revival period (following Match Point and Scoop) Unfortunately, if Allen’s newest is any indication, his most recent trends’ half-lives will be significantly shorter than his first. Critics falling over themselves to praise Allen’s “minimalism” and “directorial efficiency” ignore the plain fact that if anyone other than Woody Allen made this film, those same critics would transpose such adjectives as “boring” and “amateurish" into their reviews. Cassandra’s Dream is not a bad movie – it is simply an irrelevant one.
Dig no deeper than the film’s title to glean not only Allen’s penchant for mythology but, more pointedly, his fondness for hollow metaphors. At least the character Cassandra in Allen’s Pygmalion-inspired Mighty Aphrodite gets to exclaim, “I see disaster; I see catastrophe; Worst, I see lawyers!” Cassandra’s Dream simply refers to the name of a sailboat purchased jointly by working-class brothers Ian (Ewan McGregor) and Terry (Colin Farrell). Terry works as an auto mechanic and squanders his meager income on booze and poker games, while Ian manages his father’s London-based restaurant with an eye on bolting to
When Terry amasses a substantial gambling debt, the brothers approach their wealthy Uncle Howard (Tom Wilkinson), an expatriate plastic surgeon immersed in nefarious financial dealings. Howard agrees to get Terry out of hock and fund Ian’s shaky
A pervasive staginess makes this entire production feel like it belongs in the Old Vic more than a movie theater. Moreover, an air of laziness creeps into Allen’s script; e.g., Ian and Terry constantly refer to each by their first names during casual conversations – no one talks that way, suggesting both a mistrust of the audience’s ability to follow along and (perhaps more likely) Allen’s need for verbal bookmarks so he can keep up with which character is speaking at any given point in his own screenplay.
McGregor and Farrell’s performances vacillate madly from scene to scene: sometimes sublime, sometimes overcooked, and sometimes looking as though they are reading off cue cards. The lovely Atwell and the rest of the female cast are given little to do. Only Wilkinson acquits himself well, cutting a textured turn out of narrative whole-cloth sans the clownish gimcracks that dominate his Oscar-nominated role in Michael Clayton.
Philip Glass’ score – the first specifically written for an Allen film – is typical ethereal Glass, but it also enhances otherwise mundane scenes into ones where you find yourself anticipating a payoff that never fully arrives. Match Point proved that Allen still has some tricks up his sleeve; Cassandra’s Dream shows that he can still forget to shuffle the deck.
Neil Morris